Contradiction ledger
Which one we publish when sources disagree — and why
The quietest lie a comparison site can tell is to present a contradiction as settled. When two sources give two values for the same thing, picking one makes the record look clean; the uncertainty does not go away, it merely becomes invisible. This ledger keeps those points: who says what, which one we publish, and where we refuse to take a side.
5 contradictions · no side taken on 5
The ledger exists to show contradictions, not to resolve them
On some rows we publish one side and give the reason — for instance when one source is the manufacturer's own release and the other is a secondary source repeating it. On others there is not enough ground to take a side; then we publish neither and the row stays open. Forcing a choice would manufacture a certainty we do not have.
Product / brand record 0
Product and brand records. When two sources give different values for the same field during a verification round, the divergence is written into the record itself. Until now only the winner was recorded; the divergence itself was lost.
No contradiction is recorded in the product and brand records yet. The mechanism is in place: when two sources diverge, the divergence is written into the record and appears here. An empty list does not mean there are no contradictions — it means none has been recorded yet.
List price 2
Price lists. These rows are not written by hand but DERIVED from the data: when two different sellers publish a list price for the same screen size, the ledger puts them side by side. Near sizes are not merged — 1.54 inch and 1.6 inch may be the same panel, but "may be" is not enough to pair them. The "how many times" figure on the price index page comes out larger, and that is not a contradiction: there a whole SIZE BAND is compared (every model between 2.2 and 4.25 inches, say), whereas here only an identical size and only the single-unit price.
-
List price of the 2.9 inch label
Open4.1× difference between two sellers
What the sources say
- 248 TRY (excl. VAT, single unit) — 2,9 inç üç renk FirmaLazım · 15 August 2026
- 1,017 TRY (excl. VAT, single unit) — TM 290 C-FFS Alarm ID · 15 August 2026
Neither — the contradiction stands open
Why: Neither list records a brand. So we cannot say whether the difference comes from the product or from the channel: one seller may be pricing a three-colour panel and the other a black-and-white one. Since the site publishes no product prices, no side is taken here; the index shows only the band and the spread. The question to ask when requesting a quote: which brand, which model, at which quantity?
-
List price of the 4.2 inch label
Open4.9× difference between two sellers
What the sources say
- 392 TRY (excl. VAT, single unit) — 4,2 inç yedi renk FirmaLazım · 15 August 2026
- 1,921 TRY (excl. VAT, single unit) — TM 420 C-FFF Alarm ID · 15 August 2026
Neither — the contradiction stands open
Why: Neither list records a brand. So we cannot say whether the difference comes from the product or from the channel: one seller may be pricing a three-colour panel and the other a black-and-white one. Since the site publishes no product prices, no side is taken here; the index shows only the band and the spread. The question to ask when requesting a quote: which brand, which model, at which quantity?
Deployment figure 3
The deployment ledger. Divergences between sources on published deployment figures were already recorded and visible only on their own page; they now appear here as well.
-
Co-op — store count
OpenRecord: Co-op · United Kingdom
What the sources say
- Yaklaşık 2.400 mağaza VusionGroup bülteni ve Retail Technology Innovation Hub
- 2.300 mağazanın tamamı, 2026 sonuna kadar Retail Gazette
- 2024 sonunda 1.500 mağaza hedefi; sonraki haberlerde 2025 sonunda 1.600 Perakende basınında yayımlanan ardışık hedefler
Neither — the contradiction stands open
Why: The most instructive row in the ledger. The announced scope is ~2,400 stores, but the progress independently visible in August 2025 was 700 stores. The target date also shifts from source to source: end of 2024, end of 2025 and end of 2026 each appear in print. When a proposal says "Co-op uses them in 2,400 stores", know that this is the announced scope and does not mean a completed installation.
-
VusionGroup — the vendor installed base
OpenRecord: VusionGroup · Worldwide
What the sources say
- 650 milyon etiket, 75 bin mağaza Dolaşımdaki ansiklopedi maddesi — şirket beyanlarını aktaran ikincil kaynak
- Yaklaşık 314 milyon etiket (2025 üçüncü çeyrek sonu bulut kurulu tabanı); 2025 ilk çeyreğinde yaklaşık 26.000 mağaza ve 188 milyon etiket VusionGroup'un kendi çeyrek bülteni, 22 Ekim 2025
Neither — the contradiction stands open
Why: This row is not a chain but a VENDOR's total installed base — and the kind of figure most often confused in proposals. The sentence "used in 75,000 stores worldwide" usually traces back here. The gap between the company's own release and the figure in circulation is close to twofold; and 314 million LABELS and 26,000 STORES count entirely different things. A vendor's installed base is also not evidence that an installation will succeed in your store.
-
Walmart — store count
OpenRecord: Walmart · United States
What the sources say
- Şirket etiketi 2026'ya kadar 2.300 mağazaya yaymayı PLANLIYOR CNBC, 3 Ekim 2025
- Yaklaşık 2.300 mağazada kurulum ZATEN TAMAMLANDI; hedef 2026 sonuna kadar 5.212 ABD mağazasının tamamı The Food Institute derlemesi
Neither — the contradiction stands open
Why: Neither may be wrong — one may describe the target, the other the current state. But when a proposal says "Walmart uses them in 2,300 stores", do not use the line without asking which one it is: that difference decides whether the same sentence is a reference or a statement of intent. The ledger does not resolve the contradiction; it shows it.
Where the ledger is still empty
No contradiction is recorded in the product and brand records yet. That does not mean the catalogue holds none — it means none has been recorded yet. Divergences found in earlier verification rounds went into that round's notes as prose and were never converted into the ledger's shape. Recording them retroactively cannot be done without re-reading the sources; writing them without reading would mean inventing the contradiction.